Day 19 – DC Machines: Testing & Efficiency (ECET 2026 EEE)

Concept Notes (Deep Explanation + Examples)

🔹 Introduction

Testing and efficiency determination are among the most important topics in DC machines, especially for ECET and practical labs.
In real life, before any DC generator or motor is installed in a power plant, traction system, or control panel, it must undergo testing to check performance, losses, and efficiency.

Think of it like a medical check-up for a machine — we test its “health” before putting it into service.

---

🔹 Why Testing is Done

Testing helps to determine:

1. Efficiency of the machine
2. Losses (copper loss, iron loss, mechanical loss, stray losses)
3. Condition of insulation
4. Temperature rise and performance under load

---

🔹 Types of Tests on DC Machines

There are two main types of tests:

1️⃣ Direct Tests

Power is directly supplied to the machine, and losses are measured directly.

Examples:

• Brake Test (for DC motor)
• Load Test (for DC generator)

These tests give accurate results but are costly and power-consuming.

---

2️⃣ Indirect Tests

Losses are determined without loading the machine.
These are efficient and economical, widely used in labs.

Examples:

• Swinburne’s Test (for DC shunt machine)
• Hopkinson’s Test (for two identical DC machines)
• Field’s Test (for series machines)
• Retardation Test (for determining rotational losses)

---

🔹 Direct Test – Brake Test (for DC Motor)

In this test, the motor drives a brake drum connected to a belt or rope with two spring balances.
The difference in tension gives the braking torque.

Formula:

Power developed (mechanical output):

Where
NNN = speed in rpm
TTT = torque in N·m

Then,
Efficiency = Output Power / Input Power

Practical Example:
In electrical labs, you’ll find a DC shunt motor connected to a spring balance brake system. This is how torque and efficiency are directly calculated.

---

🔹 Indirect Test – Swinburne’s Test

This is one of the most common ECET topics.

It is done on a DC shunt motor or generator at no-load.

Steps:

1. Run the machine on no-load.
2. Measure no-load current, voltage, and field current.
3. Calculate constant losses (iron + mechanical losses).
4. Then calculate efficiency at any load current using formulas.

Advantages:

• Very simple and economical
• No need to load the machine
• Losses are easily separated

Limitation:

• Cannot determine stray load losses or temperature rise.

Real-Life Example:
In labs, Swinburne’s Test is performed to estimate the efficiency of DC machines without wasting energy — making it “eco-friendly testing.”

---

🔹 Hopkinson’s Test (Back-to-Back Test)

Also called Regenerative Test.
It requires two identical DC machines — one acts as a motor, the other as a generator.

Procedure:

• Connect the two machines mechanically and electrically.
• Supply only the losses from the mains (very economical).
• The machines circulate power between them.

Advantages:

• High accuracy
• Real-load conditions
• Measures temperature rise

Used in industries to test high-power DC machines.

Analogy:
It’s like two people pushing each other— energy keeps circulating, and you only supply the small effort lost as heat.

---

🔹 Losses in DC Machines

Losses are the reason efficiency is never 100%.

Types:

1. Copper Losses (I²R losses)
   • Armature loss:
   • Field loss:
2. Iron Losses (Core Losses)
   • Hysteresis and eddy current losses in the armature.
3. Mechanical Losses
   • Friction and windage.
4. Stray Load Losses
   • Miscellaneous small losses.

---

🔹 Efficiency of DC Machines

Efficiency (η) = Output / Input

For Generator:

For Motor:

Typical efficiencies:

• DC shunt machine: 80–90%
• DC series machine: 75–85%

---

🔹 Practical Insights (Field View)

In substations and testing labs:

• Brake Test setups are used for small DC motors.
• Hopkinson’s Test rigs are used for large industrial DC machines.
• Thermal cameras and PLC monitors track machine performance and temperature rise.

---

⚙️ Formulas (Plain LaTeX Only)

---

🔟 10 MCQs (GATE + ECET Mixed)

1. In Swinburne’s test, which losses are assumed constant?
   A) Armature copper losses
   B) Iron and mechanical losses
   C) Field copper losses
   D) Stray losses
2. Which test is suitable for determining the efficiency of two identical DC machines?
   A) Brake test
   B) Hopkinson’s test
   C) Field test
   D) Retardation test
3. In a DC motor, armature copper loss is given by:
   A)
   B)
   C)
   D)
4. The main limitation of Swinburne’s test is:
   A) It requires large power
   B) It cannot measure temperature rise
   C) It is inaccurate
   D) It is costly
5. Hopkinson’s test is also called:
   A) No-load test
   B) Retardation test
   C) Regenerative test
   D) Field test
6. In a brake test, torque is calculated using:
   A) Electrical power
   B) Speed only
   C) Difference in spring balance readings
   D) Armature current
7. Iron losses depend on:
   A) Armature current
   B) Speed and flux density
   C) Load current
   D) Resistance of field winding
8. Efficiency of a DC generator is maximum when:
   A) Iron loss = Copper loss
   B) Load current = zero
   C) Voltage = maximum
   D) Speed = constant
9. Which test is most economical for large DC machines?
   A) Brake test
   B) Swinburne’s test
   C) Hopkinson’s test
   D) Retardation test
10. Constant losses in DC machine include:
    A) Armature copper loss
    B) Field copper loss
    C) Iron and mechanical losses
    D) Brush contact loss

---

✅ Answer Key

Q.No	Answer
1	B
2	B
3	A
4	B
5	C
6	C
7	B
8	A
9	C
10	C

---

🧠 MCQ Explanations (Step-by-Step)

1️⃣ B → In Swinburne’s test, iron and mechanical losses are constant at a given speed and voltage.
2️⃣ B → Hopkinson’s test uses two identical machines, sharing energy (regenerative).
3️⃣ A → Armature copper loss = .
4️⃣ B → Swinburne’s test cannot determine temperature rise, as it’s a no-load test.
5️⃣ C → Hopkinson’s test regenerates power → regenerative test.
6️⃣ C → Torque = (S₁ – S₂) × D × g / 2.
7️⃣ B → Iron losses ∝ flux density and speed (frequency of reversal).
8️⃣ A → Maximum efficiency occurs when variable = constant losses.
9️⃣ C → Hopkinson’s test is most economical as only losses are supplied.
10️⃣ C → Iron + mechanical losses are constant → constant losses.

---

🎯 Motivation / Why Practice Matters (ECET 2026 EEE)

“Testing & Efficiency” is one of the top 5 repeatedly asked ECET EEE topics.
Understanding these tests helps you:

• Solve numerical problems confidently
• Face viva questions in DC Machines Lab
• Handle industrial test reports with real understanding

Remember — every efficient engineer must know how to test a machine properly.
Your foundation in DC testing builds confidence for Power Machines, Drives, and Power Systems.

💪 Keep revising — one topic a day = a guaranteed ECET top rank!

---

📲 CTA (Fixed)

Join our ECET 2026 EEE WhatsApp Group for daily quizzes & study notes:
https://chat.whatsapp.com/GniYuv3CYVDKjPWEN086X9

Download as PDF